Balancing human thought and AI assistance

Everyone's talking about artificial intelligence today. Companies are rushing to implement it, and leaders are trying to figure out where it fits. But in our rush to embrace AI, are we losing our own critical thinking abilities?

A recent study in Societies shows something that should worry every business leader: the more we use AI tools, the worse our critical thinking becomes. This isn't speculation - it's backed by data showing a "significant negative correlation between frequent AI tool usage and critical thinking abilities." Note: correlation does not equal causation.

Why does this matter?

Critical thinking is what separates good leaders from great ones. It helps us make complex decisions, spot opportunities, and navigate challenges. If we're losing this ability, we're in trouble.

What's happening?

The study found something called "cognitive offloading." Essentially, we're letting AI do our thinking for us. Think of it like a muscle that weakens when you don't use it. When we constantly rely on AI for analysis and decisions, we're not exercising our own critical thinking skills.

This isn't just about using AI for simple tasks. The research shows a concerning pattern of people increasingly offloading complex cognitive tasks to AI systems. Instead of analyzing data ourselves, we let AI find patterns. Rather than working through problems, we ask AI for solutions. Each time we do this, we miss an opportunity to exercise our critical thinking abilities.

Particularly concerning is that younger people are showing higher dependence on AI tools and lower critical thinking scores. These are our future leaders and decision-makers. The study found that younger participants (17-25) exhibited the highest reliance on AI tools and significantly lower scores in critical thinking assessments. They were also more likely to accept AI-generated solutions without questioning them.

The research also revealed an interesting pattern: the more people use AI tools, the more they trust them. This creates a feedback loop where increased usage leads to higher trust, which leads to more reliance and less independent thinking. For organizations, this raises serious questions about long-term decision-making capabilities.

AI should augment human intelligence, not replace it. But now, the data suggests we're heading down a path where replacement, not augmentation, is becoming the norm.

The Education Factor

There is some good news, though. The study found that higher education levels correlate with better critical thinking skills, regardless of AI usage. This suggests that solid training in analytical thinking can help maintain these capabilities even as we increase our use of AI.

But it's not just about having a degree. The research shows that people with advanced education approach AI differently. They're more likely to:

• Question AI-generated outputs

• Cross-check information from multiple sources

• Understand the limitations of AI tools

• Maintain independent analytical processes

Think about it as if learning to do math before using a calculator. If you understand the underlying principles, you can spot when something doesn't look right. You know when to trust the tool and when to double-check its work.

This matters for organizations because it suggests two things:

1. Investment in education and training isn't just about skills; it's about building cognitive resilience

2. The way we teach people to use AI is just as important as the AI tools themselves

For business leaders, this means rethinking how we approach professional development. Maybe the focus shouldn't just be on teaching people how to use AI tools but also on strengthening the fundamental thinking skills that help them use them wisely.

What Can We Do About It?

Here are four things every organization should consider:

1. Be intentional about AI use. Don't just implement AI because everyone else is. Think about where it truly adds value versus where human thinking is crucial. This means mapping out your processes and deliberately identifying which tasks benefit from AI automation and which require human critical thinking. For example, AI can handle data processing and pattern recognition but keep strategy development and complex problem-solving in human hands.

2. Create space for thinking. Ensure your teams have time and space for deep analysis and discussion, not just quick AI-generated answers. This could mean implementing "AI-free" brainstorming sessions or requiring teams to develop solutions before consulting AI tools. It's about creating deliberate opportunities for people to exercise their critical thinking muscles. The study shows that simply having time for deep thinking isn't enough - you need structured approaches that encourage active cognitive engagement.

3. Invest in training. Focus on developing critical thinking skills, especially for younger employees who might not have had as many opportunities to develop these capabilities. This isn't about traditional training programs - it's about creating real-world scenarios where people need to think critically. Consider implementing:

   • Case study analyses where teams work through complex problems without AI assistance

   • Decision-making workshops that focus on analytical thinking

   • Mentoring programs where experienced critical thinkers can share their approaches

   • Regular exercises in analyzing and questioning AI-generated outputs

4. Question everything. Foster an environment where it's not just okay but expected to question assumptions and think deeply about problems. This means creating a culture where challenging ideas are valued. Encourage your teams to ask:

   • Why did the AI reach this conclusion?

   • What assumptions might be built into this AI model?

   • What factors might the AI be missing?

   • How would we solve this problem without AI?

The key is implementation. These aren't just nice-to-have suggestions but critical strategies for maintaining cognitive capabilities in an AI-driven world. The study shows that organizations that actively maintain spaces for human critical thinking see better outcomes in decision-making and problem-solving.

Start small, but start now. Pick one of these areas and focus on it for the next quarter. Monitor how it affects your team's ability to think independently and solve problems. Then, expand to other areas based on what you learn.

Moving Forward

AI isn't going anywhere. It's a powerful tool that can help us work better and faster. But we can't let it become a crutch that weakens our ability to think critically.

The real challenge for leaders isn't implementing AI; it's maintaining and developing human intelligence alongside it. We need both. The companies that figure out this balance will be the ones that succeed in the long run. This isn't just about having AI tools and human thinkers; it's about knowing when and how to use each effectively.

Consider these scenarios:

• When analyzing market trends, start with your hypotheses before turning to AI for validation

• In strategic planning sessions, begin with human brainstorming before using AI to enhance and expand ideas

• When solving complex problems, use AI as a source of additional perspective rather than the primary solution-finder

The next time you're faced with a complex decision, try working through it without immediately turning to AI. Write down your thinking process. What assumptions are you making? What data are you considering? What experiences are you drawing from? Then, and only then, consult AI tools to see what additional insights they might offer.

The study makes one clear: the organizations that thrive in the AI era won't have the most advanced AI tools. They'll be the ones that successfully blend AI capabilities with strong human critical thinking.

Ask yourself these questions:

• How often do you rely on AI for decisions you used to make on your own?

• When was the last time you solved a complex problem without AI assistance?

• Are your teams becoming more or less capable of independent critical thinking?

• How are you measuring and maintaining critical thinking capabilities in your organization?

Are you maintaining your critical thinking abilities in the age of AI? Or are you letting technology do all the heavy lifting? The answer might determine your success in the years ahead.

AI should make us better thinkers, not replace our thinking entirely. The choice and the responsibility is ours.

If you found this post helpful, consider sharing it with another executive grappling with AI, technology, and data. If you want to explore AI and other Technology strategies, grab some time on my calendar, and let's chat.

Your next read

Navigating Our Future: AI as a Partner, Not a Replacement

Artificial intelligence is reshaping our world, subtly shifting the very fabric of human interaction. As we integrate AI into our lives, we must guard against losing the essence of being human.

Newsletter Recommendations